From the eyes of a long-time fan
It wasn't what we wanted, but it's what we got. Us: die hard fans of the Avett Brothers, grew up on a guitar/banjo/bass Avett Brothers fans, and show-a-year to keep the doctor away Avett Brothers fans. The Avett Brothers will never let you down and though it may appear that way to us, they haven't yet and why would they now. Disclaimer: The album is good, really good, just open your ears.
So what's new? You'll hear horns, see a 6th musician added to the on-stage lineup at piano, (who are they? Brad & Angelina) and a full-bodied sound that sounds more produced than
I and Love and You. These are not bad things, they're just new and sometimes that can be off-putting and in the case of this album, it may sound like they're trying too hard. They are experimenting sonically, but the lyrics are as eloquent and profound as ever, in fact it may be their strongest effort yet in this category.
If you're into their heart-gripping and soul-touching songs check out:
"February Seven"
"Through My Prayers"
The Brothers have been playing "Once and Future Carpenter," "Down With the Shine," and "Pretty Girl From Michigan" regularly live for a while now. These songs blended right in with their older material and it will only be a matter of time until "Live and Die" and "I Never Knew You" are staples of the their live sets and discography. Keep in mind the members of the band said, multiple times over, that they recorded 25-30 songs for the album. We are seeing the cream of the crop here on The Carpenter.
The Avett Brothers are as mainstream as ever now, which speaks volumes for the growth of their sound. To have transitioned in to the realm of relevance and enduring sound in today's society; they have proven themselves phenomenal musicians. This certainly is nothing we saw coming, especially when you hear a song like "
Salvation Song" where they are crooning, "we came for all that's good that's how we'll walk away." They were paid off with fame and we aren't sure that is why they came, but they sure have taken their
fair share of the spotlight.
Some good does come from all this fame. Could you think of a band whose songs carry the weight and substance of any single song from The Avett Brothers' catalogue? That's right. You could put Mumford & Sons up there, maybe (they're 5 full-lengths and a few EP's behind though). The Carpenter is literally:
just the tip...of the iceberg.
Don't take my devoted (overly devoted) word on this phenomenal album, go give it a listen for yourself.